If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Anyone with get scammed by Ebay book sellers?
I am writing a magazine article regarding the increasing amount of
fraudulent booksellers on ebay. I would love to hear stories of anyone who either has information or has themselves been scammed when trying to buy books on ebay (or even if YOU were the scammer!). I've noticed a lot of booksellers knowingly pass off Book Club Editions as first editions, as well as people who list books as first editions when they are clearly marked as later printings. I've heard stories of people selling signed books that were signed by imposters, and people who bid up their own auctions to drive the price up. I'd love any stories you may have, as well as any info you may have on who some of these sellers are. If you'd like to remain anonymous, please tell me and I will absolutely respect that. You can either post a reply here or email me directly at . Thanks, and hopefully this article will draw enough attention to this issue and have an impact, because this practice is completely out of hand! |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Most of us who purchase books from ebay are aware of the risks. The greater
the price, the more care that must be taken before placing a bid. If I chose to buy/sell a ten thousand dollar mint first edition first release Dickens for example, I would only arrange for delivery to a respected antiquarian book dealer local to the buyer or some such arrangement for the mutual protection of buyer and seller alike. It must be remembered that some of the sellers are entirely ignorant of books and the accepted descriptions of condition and the many nuances of publishing... I'm a collector. I've never sold a book in my life! I prefer to do business with antiquarian dealers... look, feel, smell etc. but some titles... -kevin |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
|
#4
|
|||
|
|||
wrote in message
... I am writing a magazine article regarding the increasing amount of fraudulent booksellers on ebay. What magazine is it for? Or is it freelance? |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
It is freelance. I'll repost here when it gets published and let you know
who picks it up. Thanks for the info on Ken Lopez. It's exactly what I'm looking for. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
"Art Layton" wrote in message om... wrote in message .. . I am writing a magazine article regarding the increasing amount of fraudulent booksellers on ebay. I would love to hear stories of anyone who either has information or has themselves been scammed when trying to buy books on ebay (or even if YOU were the scammer!). I've noticed a lot of booksellers knowingly pass off Book Club Editions as first editions, That's criminal fraud. On the other hand, people are foolish to buy books from sellers who plainly don't even know the standard terms of the bookselling trade. Even the writing quality itself is significant in a listing. What wise book buyer wants to trust his money to an on-line bookseller who either cannot write coherent English, or, if that be the case, proves too stingy and arrogant to compensate for his weakness by hiring help with halfway decent writing skills? As far as I am concerned--and the following comment is limited to situations where customers cannot see and touch the books they are buying--an ignorant, ungrammatical bookseller is about as attractive as a toothless, habitually-drooling chef. Mr. or Ms. Internet Bookseller, you will either describe your listings in grammatical English using the standard terms of the trade or you will not get my business. (And as to the book buyers, well, if you are dumb enough to buy on line from so-called booksellers who don't know their basic terminology--and exhibit an atrocious lack of writing skills too--Ebay is not going to be able to save you from yourself.) That is not to suggest that there are not some people around with good writing skills and some knowledge of books who are simply committing fraud. Ebay ratings help, but they are not fool- proof. All you can do is report perpetrators of scams to Ebay immediately. Remember that you can reduce your chances of being swindled by an on-line seller, but you can't entirely eliminate the possibility--there is an element of luck involved in on-line buying. Mr. Palmer Room 314 as well as people who list books as first editions when they are clearly marked as later printings. snip Go to abaa.org and look for Ken Lopez's letter to eBay about fraud. Lookin the right hand column and scroll down. Art Layton Stamford CT |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
palmer.william wrote:
As far as I am concerned--and the following comment is limited to situations where customers cannot see and touch the books they are buying--an ignorant, ungrammatical bookseller is about as attractive as a toothless, habitually-drooling chef. Oh, I don't know. I did quite well buying from a lady selling a copy of something she called "Under the Milk Weed" by Dylan Thomas and - among other finds - I have several times picked up for just a few dollars 19th century works of which there are a dozen or fewer copies listed in libraries worldwide. The fact that the seller cannot spell the title of the book he or she is selling, or do the rudimentary amount of work needed to see whether it might have some scarcity or collectible value is part of the attraction of eBay. Sellers who cannot write a book description very often know next to nothing about books. Of course, some of them are idiots who think their 1924 Grosset and Dunlap edition of Great Expectations is worth hundreds, if not thousands, of dollars, but they are easily ignored. The ones to keep an eye out for are the ones who've listed a first UK edition of a Leonard Cohen book in the poetry section, rather than as a collectible book, neglected to mention that it *is* the UK first, or that it is actually the hardback version, not the paperback that usually circulates, or that it is in a very creditable dust jacket (to give another recent example of a book I bought and resold on eBay). In such cases, one or two questions just to sort out the basics - Who is the publisher? Are all the pages present and attached to the book? - or to clear up issue points - What is the price on the dust jacket? Does it have an advertisement for such-and-such at the back of the book? - and, hey presto, a sleeper has been awoken. Of course, sometimes the questions can alert the seller; asking whether the misprint on line 23 of page 147 is present could make even an ignorant seller aware that It Might Matter. But that's all part of the game. Mr. or Ms. Internet Bookseller, you will either describe your listings in grammatical English using the standard terms of the trade or you will not get my business. Well, but I hope you will try googling and checking sellers' descriptions on ABE, just to make sure those impeccably-written descriptions haven't been lifted lock, stock and barrel from someone else - a popular sport among many eBay sellers. I buy from articulate and well-informed buyers as well, of course. But God bless those sellers who don't know their colophons from their elbow! -- John http://rarebooksinjapan.com |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
palmer.william wrote:
Mr. or Ms. Internet Bookseller, you will either describe your listings in grammatical English using the standard terms of the trade or you will not get my business. (And as to the book buyers, well, if you are dumb enough to buy on line from so-called booksellers who don't know their basic terminology--and exhibit an atrocious lack of writing skills too--Ebay is not going to be able to save you from yourself.) Although I basically agree with this, I'd like to add one caveat: That the seller can suffer when s/he uses standard terms correctly and the buyer does not. I've seen negative feedback resulting from a book's condition being described as "good" (in the trade standard sense) but not being up to the buyer's idea of "good" (in a more colloquial sense). Sometimes you can't win. Cathy Krusberg Internet: |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Cathy Krusberg wrote in message ...
...I'd like to add one caveat: That the seller can suffer when s/he uses standard terms correctly and the buyer does not. I've seen negative feedback resulting from a book's condition being described as "good" (in the trade standard sense) but not being up to the buyer's idea of "good" (in a more colloquial sense). Sometimes you can't win. Yep, and I think this usually happens when you have buyer's remorse: the buyer feels she paid a bit too much for the book, or were expecting something more for the price. With a bargain buy, you'll rarely hear this nitpicking about quality. And then you've also got those buyers who just can't believe, despite being told repeatedly before and after ordering, that shipping by media mail to their destination can take up to 14 days. -- Ht |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Whenever I advertise (it's rare, unless I come across a duplicate or something
I don't want anymore), I capitalize and bold the terms: "The item is in Good condition," for example, with Good in bold face. A close-up scan also helps. Ht is right, though. Often, the people who are upset about condition are the ones who got in a bidding war and wound up paying a lot. I did have a guy try to "upgrade" his beat up item by telling me that mine got mangled in the mail. Photos revealed that his item and mine were not the same! So, watch out for buyers as well as sellers. Most of the sellers who rip me off just take my money and give me nothing!! Frank |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Ebay autograph policy | Gummby3 | Autographs | 0 | April 16th 04 01:29 AM |
do not forward OFF this group that Xlist | dahoov2 | Autographs | 4 | March 9th 04 04:45 AM |
[FAQ] rec.collecting.books FAQ | Mike Berro | Books | 0 | December 26th 03 09:18 PM |
autographs | dani.steiner | General | 0 | July 19th 03 06:08 AM |
Reducing Autograph Collection | dani.steiner | Autographs | 0 | July 16th 03 02:29 PM |