A collecting forum. CollectingBanter

If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Go Back   Home » CollectingBanter forum » Collecting newsgroups » Coins
Site Map Home Register Authors List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Web Partners

Market grading vs. Technical Grading.....the answer to my coin grading question



 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old July 20th 05, 12:42 AM
Ira Stein
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Market grading vs. Technical Grading.....the answer to my coin grading question

Earlier today, I illustrated my response to a discussion of market
grading vs. technical grading and an example of two 1879-CC $1 that
were thought to be VF-30 and VF-35 respectively were graded EF-45 and
AU-55 by PCGS. Much lamenting and gnashing of teeth followed, with
teras flowing copiously against teh evils of market grading.

About 11 or twelve of you kind Rcc'ers were asked for an opinion of
this PCGS graded 1797 Half Dollar:

http://members.aol.com/iras4/1797HfDolpcgs.jpg

Larry Louks answered Fine with possibly VF, but others suggested grades
ranging from VF-20 to POSSIBLY EF-40. One of you checked your ANA
grading guide for the answere and suggested a grade of VF-25.

Now, for the rest of the story, as Paul Harvey likes to say.

I also posed this question as to grade to about 46 local coin cub
members at one of our local meetings. Two though the coin was no better
than VG if that due to the denominator of the 1/2 on reverse being
"worn away" (sic) and the fact that the rim was incomplete on both
sides. Most of the others thought VF and a couple thought EF and 2
others, IIRC, thought it was a Fine.

This coin had been in an NGC VF-20 holder, graded recently (in last 8
mos. or so) and been submitted 3X to PCGS for a possible upgrade, or at
least a crossover at VF-20. No brainer, right?

Each of the 3X, PCGS came up with the same grade! Which was....(drum
roll)............................
..................................
..................................


Fine -15!


Larry Loucks was right on the money with his Fine & possibly VF-20
guess, and he does not have the experience of many of the long in tooth
old *******s like myself who have been around in this field for many
more years than Larry.

PCGS has market graded the coin, and I used this as an illustration of
market grading being a two way street. The coin is dark, and the market
likes coins either white, light gray, or nearly so, and will tolerate
only lovely rainbow toning near the rims if it's not pure white! Of
course, the blueish dark gray toning of the coin shows an untampered
piece, but that won't garner a higher point grade. In fact, in detail,
the coin is nearly a perfect match for teh VF illustrated in Al
Overton's epic book on Bust Halves, and that book was published over 20
years ago!

Here's more.

The dealer thought he stole the coin in its NGC holder for $50,000,
felt confident he could make a fast $10-$12K by getting it graded VF25
by PCGs and at least $4-$5K even if it crossed at VF-20.

I bought it from him for $45,000 and sold it for $47,800. Certainly
brought very strong money for a Fine, but the coin had the detail of a
higher graded piece.

Thought the whole deal was kinda interesting and thought I'd share it
with y'all.

Ira

Ads
  #2  
Old July 20th 05, 01:10 AM
Larry Louks
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default

"Ira Stein" heaped copious praises and accolades on Larry with:
Larry Louks was right on the money with his Fine & possibly VF-20
guess, and he does not have the experience of many of the long in tooth
old *******s like myself who have been around in this field for many
more years than Larry.


Heh heh! Heck, I think that's the first coin of that series that I've ever
graded, Ira. We might need to chalk that one up to "beginner's luck." In any
case, I'm pleased to hear that I was that close to what the slabbers saw in
the coin.


Thought the whole deal was kinda interesting and thought I'd share it
with y'all.


Thanks for sharing! That is indeed quite a story!

Larry
'even a blind hog finds an acorn every once in a while'



  #3  
Old July 20th 05, 01:10 AM
reality
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default



Ira Stein wrote:
Earlier today, I illustrated my response to a discussion of market
grading vs. technical grading and an example of two 1879-CC $1 that
were thought to be VF-30 and VF-35 respectively were graded EF-45 and
AU-55 by PCGS. Much lamenting and gnashing of teeth followed, with
teras flowing copiously against teh evils of market grading.

About 11 or twelve of you kind Rcc'ers were asked for an opinion of
this PCGS graded 1797 Half Dollar:

http://members.aol.com/iras4/1797HfDolpcgs.jpg

Larry Louks answered Fine with possibly VF, but others suggested grades
ranging from VF-20 to POSSIBLY EF-40. One of you checked your ANA
grading guide for the answere and suggested a grade of VF-25.

Now, for the rest of the story, as Paul Harvey likes to say.

I also posed this question as to grade to about 46 local coin cub
members at one of our local meetings. Two though the coin was no better
than VG if that due to the denominator of the 1/2 on reverse being
"worn away" (sic) and the fact that the rim was incomplete on both
sides. Most of the others thought VF and a couple thought EF and 2
others, IIRC, thought it was a Fine.

This coin had been in an NGC VF-20 holder, graded recently (in last 8
mos. or so) and been submitted 3X to PCGS for a possible upgrade, or at
least a crossover at VF-20. No brainer, right?

Each of the 3X, PCGS came up with the same grade! Which was....(drum
roll)............................
.................................
.................................


Fine -15!


Larry Loucks was right on the money with his Fine & possibly VF-20
guess, and he does not have the experience of many of the long in tooth
old *******s like myself who have been around in this field for many
more years than Larry.

PCGS has market graded the coin, and I used this as an illustration of
market grading being a two way street. The coin is dark, and the market
likes coins either white, light gray, or nearly so, and will tolerate
only lovely rainbow toning near the rims if it's not pure white! Of
course, the blueish dark gray toning of the coin shows an untampered
piece, but that won't garner a higher point grade. In fact, in detail,
the coin is nearly a perfect match for teh VF illustrated in Al
Overton's epic book on Bust Halves, and that book was published over 20
years ago!

Here's more.

The dealer thought he stole the coin in its NGC holder for $50,000,
felt confident he could make a fast $10-$12K by getting it graded VF25
by PCGs and at least $4-$5K even if it crossed at VF-20.

I bought it from him for $45,000 and sold it for $47,800. Certainly
brought very strong money for a Fine, but the coin had the detail of a
higher graded piece.

Thought the whole deal was kinda interesting and thought I'd share it
with y'all.

Ira


Very interesting grading challenge. The reason I guessed VF-20 was
because of the strength of the obverse details on most of the hair and
the date, and because the obverse also has a pleasing patina to my eye.
I gave it the benefit of the doubt on what looks like a slightly weak
strike on the reverse considering it's a 1797, and although it is dark,
that didn't really bother me because of the overall originality.

  #4  
Old July 20th 05, 01:42 AM
James Higby
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default


"Ira Stein" wrote in message
ups.com...
Fine -15!


PCGS has market graded the coin, and I used this as an illustration of
market grading being a two way street. The coin is dark, and the market
likes coins either white, light gray, or nearly so, and will tolerate
only lovely rainbow toning near the rims if it's not pure white! Of
course, the blueish dark gray toning of the coin shows an untampered
piece, but that won't garner a higher point grade. In fact, in detail,
the coin is nearly a perfect match for teh VF illustrated in Al
Overton's epic book on Bust Halves, and that book was published over 20
years ago!


I'm speechless.

No, that's a lie, I've got plenty to say.

Is this an April Fool?

Are we all on Candid Camera?

In my view that coin is massively more desirable than any white or light
gray coin. It is just plain handsome. My guess of PCGS VF35 was based on
that bias of mine. I fully expected my guess to be blown away by the
revelation of an XF40 or 45 slab grade.

F-15! I'd buy slabbed halves that looked like that all day at that level
(if I could afford to do so).

The guy who paid to get that coin slabbed got robbed - thrice.

If it's a perfect match for Al Overton's VF plate coin, what gives with the
F-15?

How many dealers do we know who would offer that coin at VF30 to XF40 if it
were raw? 100? 200? 500? How many of those are respected members of the
Priesthood of Numismatics?

Why can't I ever find F-15 coins that look like that?

I want my Mommy.

Jimmy





  #5  
Old July 20th 05, 02:08 AM
Alan Williams
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default

James Higby wrote:

"Ira Stein" wrote in message
ups.com...
Fine -15!


PCGS has market graded the coin, and I used this as an illustration of
market grading being a two way street. The coin is dark, and the market
likes coins either white, light gray, or nearly so, and will tolerate
only lovely rainbow toning near the rims if it's not pure white! Of
course, the blueish dark gray toning of the coin shows an untampered
piece, but that won't garner a higher point grade. In fact, in detail,
the coin is nearly a perfect match for teh VF illustrated in Al
Overton's epic book on Bust Halves, and that book was published over 20
years ago!


I'm speechless.

No, that's a lie, I've got plenty to say.

Is this an April Fool?

Are we all on Candid Camera?

In my view that coin is massively more desirable than any white or light
gray coin. It is just plain handsome. My guess of PCGS VF35 was based on
that bias of mine. I fully expected my guess to be blown away by the
revelation of an XF40 or 45 slab grade.

F-15! I'd buy slabbed halves that looked like that all day at that level
(if I could afford to do so).

The guy who paid to get that coin slabbed got robbed - thrice.

If it's a perfect match for Al Overton's VF plate coin, what gives with the
F-15?

How many dealers do we know who would offer that coin at VF30 to XF40 if it
were raw? 100? 200? 500? How many of those are respected members of the
Priesthood of Numismatics?

Why can't I ever find F-15 coins that look like that?

I want my Mommy.

Jimmy


I'm with you, man. I'm a complete Know-Nothing about early Dollars, but
that obverse detail suggested far better than an F-15 to me.

Alan
'the eye of the beholder betrayed by the holder'
  #6  
Old July 20th 05, 02:45 AM
jeff
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Ira Stein wrote:
Earlier today, I illustrated my response to a discussion of market
grading vs. technical grading and an example of two 1879-CC $1 that
were thought to be VF-30 and VF-35 respectively were graded EF-45 and
AU-55 by PCGS. Much lamenting and gnashing of teeth followed, with
teras flowing copiously against teh evils of market grading.

About 11 or twelve of you kind Rcc'ers were asked for an opinion of
this PCGS graded 1797 Half Dollar:

http://members.aol.com/iras4/1797HfDolpcgs.jpg

Larry Louks answered Fine with possibly VF, but others suggested grades
ranging from VF-20 to POSSIBLY EF-40. One of you checked your ANA
grading guide for the answere and suggested a grade of VF-25.

Now, for the rest of the story, as Paul Harvey likes to say.

I also posed this question as to grade to about 46 local coin cub
members at one of our local meetings. Two though the coin was no better
than VG if that due to the denominator of the 1/2 on reverse being
"worn away" (sic) and the fact that the rim was incomplete on both
sides. Most of the others thought VF and a couple thought EF and 2
others, IIRC, thought it was a Fine.

This coin had been in an NGC VF-20 holder, graded recently (in last 8
mos. or so) and been submitted 3X to PCGS for a possible upgrade, or at
least a crossover at VF-20. No brainer, right?

Each of the 3X, PCGS came up with the same grade! Which was....(drum
roll)............................
.................................
.................................


Fine -15!


Larry Loucks was right on the money with his Fine & possibly VF-20
guess, and he does not have the experience of many of the long in tooth
old *******s like myself who have been around in this field for many
more years than Larry.

PCGS has market graded the coin, and I used this as an illustration of
market grading being a two way street. The coin is dark, and the market
likes coins either white, light gray, or nearly so, and will tolerate
only lovely rainbow toning near the rims if it's not pure white! Of
course, the blueish dark gray toning of the coin shows an untampered
piece, but that won't garner a higher point grade. In fact, in detail,
the coin is nearly a perfect match for teh VF illustrated in Al
Overton's epic book on Bust Halves, and that book was published over 20
years ago!

Here's more.

The dealer thought he stole the coin in its NGC holder for $50,000,
felt confident he could make a fast $10-$12K by getting it graded VF25
by PCGs and at least $4-$5K even if it crossed at VF-20.

I bought it from him for $45,000 and sold it for $47,800. Certainly
brought very strong money for a Fine, but the coin had the detail of a
higher graded piece.

Thought the whole deal was kinda interesting and thought I'd share it
with y'all.

Ira

I'm certainly no expert (and apparently, per my guess, I'm pretty
optimistic , but from what I can see, F15 seems way too low. You've
given me another reason to criticize market grading. In my perfect
world, grading would be objective, and the market value of a coin would
be determined by looking at, and buying/selling, it.

BTW, Ira, this was a great exercise - very instructive. Thanks!

Jeff

Jeff
  #7  
Old July 20th 05, 02:59 AM
James Higby
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default


"Alan Williams" wrote in message
...
James Higby wrote:

"Ira Stein" wrote in message
ups.com...
Fine -15!


PCGS has market graded the coin, and I used this as an illustration of
market grading being a two way street. The coin is dark, and the market
likes coins either white, light gray, or nearly so, and will tolerate
only lovely rainbow toning near the rims if it's not pure white! Of
course, the blueish dark gray toning of the coin shows an untampered
piece, but that won't garner a higher point grade. In fact, in detail,
the coin is nearly a perfect match for teh VF illustrated in Al
Overton's epic book on Bust Halves, and that book was published over 20
years ago!


I'm speechless.

No, that's a lie, I've got plenty to say.

Is this an April Fool?

Are we all on Candid Camera?

In my view that coin is massively more desirable than any white or light
gray coin. It is just plain handsome. My guess of PCGS VF35 was based
on
that bias of mine. I fully expected my guess to be blown away by the
revelation of an XF40 or 45 slab grade.

F-15! I'd buy slabbed halves that looked like that all day at that level
(if I could afford to do so).

The guy who paid to get that coin slabbed got robbed - thrice.

If it's a perfect match for Al Overton's VF plate coin, what gives with
the
F-15?

How many dealers do we know who would offer that coin at VF30 to XF40 if
it
were raw? 100? 200? 500? How many of those are respected members of
the
Priesthood of Numismatics?

Why can't I ever find F-15 coins that look like that?

I want my Mommy.

Jimmy


I'm with you, man. I'm a complete Know-Nothing about early Dollars, but
that obverse detail suggested far better than an F-15 to me.

Alan
'the eye of the beholder betrayed by the holder'


For the record, it's a half dollar.

But I have seen countless draped bust/small eagle dollars in PCGS VF35 and
better holders that possessed detail exactly like that on the obverse. I
know that in a sense it's apples and oranges, but in another it really
isn't, especially if you look at the pictures and descriptions in the
grading guides.

James
'that was an excellent tag line, Alan'


  #8  
Old July 20th 05, 03:06 AM
Bruce H (BoxTurtle)
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default

On Tue, 19 Jul 2005 21:08:14 -0400, Alan Williams
is alleged to have written:
James Higby wrote:

"Ira Stein" wrote in message
ups.com...
Fine -15!


PCGS has market graded the coin, and I used this as an illustration of
market grading being a two way street. The coin is dark, and the market
likes coins either white, light gray, or nearly so, and will tolerate
only lovely rainbow toning near the rims if it's not pure white! Of
course, the blueish dark gray toning of the coin shows an untampered
piece, but that won't garner a higher point grade. In fact, in detail,
the coin is nearly a perfect match for teh VF illustrated in Al
Overton's epic book on Bust Halves, and that book was published over 20
years ago!


I'm speechless.

No, that's a lie, I've got plenty to say.

Is this an April Fool?

Are we all on Candid Camera?

In my view that coin is massively more desirable than any white or light
gray coin. It is just plain handsome. My guess of PCGS VF35 was based on
that bias of mine. I fully expected my guess to be blown away by the
revelation of an XF40 or 45 slab grade.

F-15! I'd buy slabbed halves that looked like that all day at that level
(if I could afford to do so).

The guy who paid to get that coin slabbed got robbed - thrice.

If it's a perfect match for Al Overton's VF plate coin, what gives with the
F-15?

How many dealers do we know who would offer that coin at VF30 to XF40 if it
were raw? 100? 200? 500? How many of those are respected members of the
Priesthood of Numismatics?

Why can't I ever find F-15 coins that look like that?

I want my Mommy.

Jimmy


I'm with you, man. I'm a complete Know-Nothing about early Dollars, but
that obverse detail suggested far better than an F-15 to me.

Alan
'the eye of the beholder betrayed by the holder'


I called it VF35. I was only adding 5 points for a weak strike. I'll
buy F15's all day if they look like that.

Bruce

*************************************************
ANA R162074
EAC 3606

To email me, remember that RoadRunner
and Coyote do not mix.
*************************************************
  #9  
Old July 20th 05, 03:44 AM
Mark Cooper
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default

"Ira Stein" wrote in news:1121816576.350216.67530
@g43g2000cwa.googlegroups.com:

Earlier today, I illustrated my response to a discussion of market
grading vs. technical grading and an example of two 1879-CC $1 that
were thought to be VF-30 and VF-35 respectively were graded EF-45 and
AU-55 by PCGS. Much lamenting and gnashing of teeth followed, with
teras flowing copiously against teh evils of market grading.

About 11 or twelve of you kind Rcc'ers were asked for an opinion of
this PCGS graded 1797 Half Dollar:

http://members.aol.com/iras4/1797HfDolpcgs.jpg

Larry Louks answered Fine with possibly VF, but others suggested grades
ranging from VF-20 to POSSIBLY EF-40. One of you checked your ANA
grading guide for the answere and suggested a grade of VF-25.

Now, for the rest of the story, as Paul Harvey likes to say.

I also posed this question as to grade to about 46 local coin cub
members at one of our local meetings. Two though the coin was no better
than VG if that due to the denominator of the 1/2 on reverse being
"worn away" (sic) and the fact that the rim was incomplete on both
sides. Most of the others thought VF and a couple thought EF and 2
others, IIRC, thought it was a Fine.

This coin had been in an NGC VF-20 holder, graded recently (in last 8
mos. or so) and been submitted 3X to PCGS for a possible upgrade, or at
least a crossover at VF-20. No brainer, right?

Each of the 3X, PCGS came up with the same grade! Which was....(drum
roll)............................
.................................
.................................


Fine -15!


Larry Loucks was right on the money with his Fine & possibly VF-20
guess, and he does not have the experience of many of the long in tooth
old *******s like myself who have been around in this field for many
more years than Larry.

PCGS has market graded the coin, and I used this as an illustration of
market grading being a two way street. The coin is dark, and the market
likes coins either white, light gray, or nearly so, and will tolerate
only lovely rainbow toning near the rims if it's not pure white! Of
course, the blueish dark gray toning of the coin shows an untampered
piece, but that won't garner a higher point grade. In fact, in detail,
the coin is nearly a perfect match for teh VF illustrated in Al
Overton's epic book on Bust Halves, and that book was published over 20
years ago!

Here's more.

The dealer thought he stole the coin in its NGC holder for $50,000,
felt confident he could make a fast $10-$12K by getting it graded VF25
by PCGs and at least $4-$5K even if it crossed at VF-20.

I bought it from him for $45,000 and sold it for $47,800. Certainly
brought very strong money for a Fine, but the coin had the detail of a
higher graded piece.

Thought the whole deal was kinda interesting and thought I'd share it
with y'all.

Ira


Very interesting exercise.

And how refreshing, a coin related thread!


Mark
  #10  
Old July 20th 05, 10:24 PM
Gary Loveless
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default



Fine -15!


Larry Loucks was right on the money with his Fine & possibly VF-20
guess, and he does not have the experience of many of the long in tooth
old *******s like myself who have been around in this field for many
more years than Larry.


Ira -

Thanks for the story! It was quite nice!

Gary


 




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Coin grading/authentication services -- periodic post Linda Coins 6 August 8th 03 06:25 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:32 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2018, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright 2004-2018 CollectingBanter.
The comments are property of their posters.