CollectingBanter

CollectingBanter (http://www.collectingbanter.com/index.php)
-   Paper Money (http://www.collectingbanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=8)
-   -   CU issues warning about comments on PCGS currency grading (http://www.collectingbanter.com/showthread.php?t=136539)

stonej July 8th 05 10:54 AM

CU issues warning about comments on PCGS currency grading
 
The director of PCGS currency grading has issued a warning in the
CU currency forum about comments being made on the PCGS currency
grading system and says they will monitor the forum.

Have they ever done something similar about coins in the CU coin
forum?


Bob Peterson July 8th 05 11:52 AM

Is he banning negative comments about their grading system? or just
mentioning they are monitoring the forum?

I would have a hard time believing they don't monitor the forum.

It is after all their forum and they probably would prefer not to see
certain things show up there.

"stonej" wrote in message
ups.com...
The director of PCGS currency grading has issued a warning in the
CU currency forum about comments being made on the PCGS currency
grading system and says they will monitor the forum.

Have they ever done something similar about coins in the CU coin
forum?




stonej July 8th 05 12:38 PM



Bob Peterson wrote:
Is he banning negative comments about their grading system? or just
mentioning they are monitoring the forum?

I would have a hard time believing they don't monitor the forum.

It is after all their forum and they probably would prefer not to see
certain things show up there.

"stonej" wrote in message
ups.com...
The director of PCGS currency grading has issued a warning in the
CU currency forum about comments being made on the PCGS currency
grading system and says they will monitor the forum.

Have they ever done something similar about coins in the CU coin
forum?



He said that while they don't want to turn the forum into
a private police state they are concerned about "personal attacks or
libelous remarks".


stonej July 8th 05 12:55 PM



stonej wrote:
Bob Peterson wrote:
Is he banning negative comments about their grading system? or just
mentioning they are monitoring the forum?

I would have a hard time believing they don't monitor the forum.

It is after all their forum and they probably would prefer not to see
certain things show up there.

"stonej" wrote in message
ups.com...
The director of PCGS currency grading has issued a warning in the
CU currency forum about comments being made on the PCGS currency
grading system and says they will monitor the forum.

Have they ever done something similar about coins in the CU coin
forum?



He said that while they don't want to turn the forum into
a private police state they are concerned about "personal attacks or
libelous remarks".



One dealer in particular has been under heavy criticism by certain
people in the forum and I think CU might be concerned about being
held responsible for what was said about him since they own the
forum.


Ira Stein July 8th 05 03:39 PM



stonej wrote:
stonej wrote:
Bob Peterson wrote:
Is he banning negative comments about their grading system? or just
mentioning they are monitoring the forum?

I would have a hard time believing they don't monitor the forum.

It is after all their forum and they probably would prefer not to see
certain things show up there.

"stonej" wrote in message
ups.com...
The director of PCGS currency grading has issued a warning in the
CU currency forum about comments being made on the PCGS currency
grading system and says they will monitor the forum.

Have they ever done something similar about coins in the CU coin
forum?



He said that while they don't want to turn the forum into
a private police state they are concerned about "personal attacks or
libelous remarks".



One dealer in particular has been under heavy criticism by certain
people in the forum and I think CU might be concerned about being
held responsible for what was said about him since they own the
forum.



I don't think it was so much that but the criticism of CGA and its
owner, Jesse Lipka, that prompted Jason Bradford's post. There was also
criticism of certain dealer(s) that sell CGA material that also came
into discussion, some of it negative, tht prompted his warning. CGA has
been around the longest and has graded over 60,000 notes, the bulk of
the third party graded notes whereas both PMG and PCGS have only
graded a tiny amountso far, as they are the new boys on the block. From
what I've seeen, PMG and PCGS have been stricter than CGA, but like
grading companies for coins, long term market demand will eventually
sort things out, hopefully.

Ira


LM5403 July 24th 05 04:14 AM

The epay mentality strikes again!

Please come in, feel free to do whatever you want.

However, if We in Our infinite wisdom decide We do not like something, We
will BAN YOU TO HELL!!!!!!!

"Stujoe" wrote in message
.net...
stonej spoke thusly...
The director of PCGS currency grading has issued a warning in the
CU currency forum about comments being made on the PCGS currency
grading system and says they will monitor the forum.

Have they ever done something similar about coins in the CU coin
forum?


I think they just did about the Coingate stories. ;)

--
Stujoe
http://www.Stujoe.com
http://www.CoinWiki.com
http://www.NumisLinks.com




Frank Provasek July 24th 05 09:30 AM

They own the board. They do not charge membership. They have the right to
delete messages for any or no reason.

--
RARE COIN AUCTIONS NO MINIMUMS www.frankcoins.com
http://search.ebay.com/_W0QQsassZfrankcoins Texas Auction License 11259
Board member of Texas Coin Dealers Association, Fort Worth Coin Club.
Member: Texas Numismatic Assoc, American Numismatic Assoc
"LM5403" wrote in message
. ..
The epay mentality strikes again!

Please come in, feel free to do whatever you want.

However, if We in Our infinite wisdom decide We do not like something, We
will BAN YOU TO HELL!!!!!!!

"Stujoe" wrote in message
.net...
stonej spoke thusly...
The director of PCGS currency grading has issued a warning in the
CU currency forum about comments being made on the PCGS currency
grading system and says they will monitor the forum.

Have they ever done something similar about coins in the CU coin
forum?


I think they just did about the Coingate stories. ;)

--
Stujoe
http://www.Stujoe.com
http://www.CoinWiki.com
http://www.NumisLinks.com






LM5403 July 24th 05 09:35 AM

You are correct.

Your point in pointing out the obvious is.........?

"Frank Provasek" wrote in message
nk.net...
They own the board. They do not charge membership. They have the right
to
delete messages for any or no reason.

--
RARE COIN AUCTIONS NO MINIMUMS www.frankcoins.com
http://search.ebay.com/_W0QQsassZfrankcoins Texas Auction License 11259
Board member of Texas Coin Dealers Association, Fort Worth Coin Club.
Member: Texas Numismatic Assoc, American Numismatic Assoc
"LM5403" wrote in message
. ..
The epay mentality strikes again!

Please come in, feel free to do whatever you want.

However, if We in Our infinite wisdom decide We do not like something, We
will BAN YOU TO HELL!!!!!!!

"Stujoe" wrote in message
.net...
stonej spoke thusly...
The director of PCGS currency grading has issued a warning in the
CU currency forum about comments being made on the PCGS currency
grading system and says they will monitor the forum.

Have they ever done something similar about coins in the CU coin
forum?

I think they just did about the Coingate stories. ;)

--
Stujoe
http://www.Stujoe.com
http://www.CoinWiki.com
http://www.NumisLinks.com








moneyking July 25th 05 03:10 AM

More free money!More free bonus!!!
http://banner.grandonline.com/cgi-bi...i?moneyking888
http://banner.aspinallsonlinecasino....i?moneyking888


MORE......
Visit us at:
http://www32.websamba.com/moneyking


"LM5403" wrote in message ...
You are correct.

Your point in pointing out the obvious is.........?

"Frank Provasek" wrote in message
nk.net...
They own the board. They do not charge membership. They have the right
to
delete messages for any or no reason.

--
RARE COIN AUCTIONS NO MINIMUMS www.frankcoins.com
http://search.ebay.com/_W0QQsassZfrankcoins Texas Auction License 11259
Board member of Texas Coin Dealers Association, Fort Worth Coin Club.
Member: Texas Numismatic Assoc, American Numismatic Assoc
"LM5403" wrote in message
. ..
The epay mentality strikes again!

Please come in, feel free to do whatever you want.

However, if We in Our infinite wisdom decide We do not like something, We
will BAN YOU TO HELL!!!!!!!

"Stujoe" wrote in message
.net...
stonej spoke thusly...
The director of PCGS currency grading has issued a warning in the
CU currency forum about comments being made on the PCGS currency
grading system and says they will monitor the forum.

Have they ever done something similar about coins in the CU coin
forum?

I think they just did about the Coingate stories. ;)

--
Stujoe
http://www.Stujoe.com
http://www.CoinWiki.com
http://www.NumisLinks.com






All times are GMT +1. The time now is 08:04 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
CollectingBanter.com